Immigration and displacement

I read Zadie Smith's "White Teeth" a while ago and it got me thinking about that feeling of displacement that immigrants feel in their adopted country. Neither of my parents grew up in America and I know that both of them have had quite strong longings over the years to be back in their countries of birth. (Those feelings exacerbated particularly when this country is in the grip of one or another right wing agenda.) Their experiences were eased by the fact that they came from English speaking countries and are both white, but cultural differences exist nonetheless. As Zadie Smith explores, the displacement becomes even stronger when their children are born in the new country and have no connection to the countries of the parents' birth. The children feel a strong need to fit in and often try to distance themselves from their parents' culture as a way of asserting their own identity and aligning themselves with the country and culture they are a part of right now.

The immigration debate going on right now borders on the ridiculous. Here we are, a nation of immigrants and as they say about environmentalists ("an environmentalist is just a person who already bought their country house") those of us who are already safely "in" and have our citizenship are going to try and keep out anyone new? Or is this at base, just racism raising it's ugly head again? Do Americans have a problem with Eastern European immigrants or is it just Mexicans and Arabs we don't want crossing our borders? I liked Bloomberg's very practical answer to someone's question about the immigration debate. He pointed out that while there are in fact many people here illegally, we must take responsibility for turning a blind eye to the laws already in place. (Businesses have taken advantage of illegal immigrants and their vulnerability for years, to boost their bottom line.) Not to mention, that if we want social security to be there when our generation needs it, we NEED immigrant workers and the taxes they pay in order to fund the program. Birth rates in this country are getting lower and lower and there are just not enough American citizens to sustain social security if we closed the borders. On a practical level, it just makes sense. On a human level, isolationism is a recipe for ruin in my opinion. It is only through interacting with other cultures that true understanding takes place.